Fiorto was drafted 10th overall by the Bayhawks in the 2012 MLL Collegiate Draft.
Fiorto played college lacrosse at Princeton University, where he was a four-year starter and one of the best goaltenders in the country. He was a four-time All-American and All-Ivy selection. Tyler played 3,396 minutes for the Tigers, recording 8 goals against an average of 7.47 and 624 saves for a percentage of .592.
Fiorto played lacrosse, soccer, and basketball at McDonogh High School. He was a two-time All-Met selection, two-time All-American, Baltimore Metro Player of the Year, and Inside Lacrosse's number two overall incoming freshman.
Fiorto was born on September 22, 1989, to Richard and Dina Fiorito. He graduated from Princeton University in 2012.